Freaks (1932)
Freaks is a 1932 American pre-Code horror film directed by Tod Browning for MGM, made with real sideshow performers.
There is a wedding at the heart of this film, and it is the warmest scene in it — until it turns. A whole troupe of performers gathers around a table, passes a loving cup from hand to hand, and welcomes a stranger in with a chant. Then the stranger spits the welcome back in their faces. Everything that follows comes from that one moment.
Freaks is a 1932 American pre-Code horror drama, produced and directed by Tod Browning for Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer. It is set in a travelling circus, and it was made with real working sideshow performers — not actors in makeup, not tricks of the camera. That is the first thing to understand about it, and the thing that made it impossible for audiences in 1932 to look away from, or to forgive.
The story
Hans is a sideshow performer with dwarfism, engaged to Frieda, another performer with dwarfism. He falls for Cleopatra, the circus’s trapeze artist, a beautiful woman who finds him ridiculous — until she learns he has inherited a large fortune.
Cleopatra marries him anyway. Her lover is Hercules, the strongman, and together they plan to poison Hans slowly and take the money. At the wedding feast, the other performers welcome Cleopatra as one of their own, chanting as they pass the loving cup: “We accept her, we accept her, one of us, one of us. Gooble gobble, gooble gobble.” Cleopatra is drunk, disgusted, and kissing Hercules in front of her new husband. She calls the performers dirty, slimy freaks. She humiliates Hans by carrying him around on her shoulders like a child.
Hans falls ill from the poison. Then he and the other performers plot together. On a stormy night, as the caravans move on, they go after Cleopatra and Hercules. Hercules is stopped from killing Venus, the sea-lion trainer. Cleopatra runs into the woods, and the performers follow her with knives.
The film does not show what they do to her. It shows what is left. Some time later, Cleopatra is on display at a carnival as a grotesque “human duck” — her legs gone, one eye out. In the version Browning first made, Hercules was also shown afterwards, singing in a falsetto voice.
There is another ending, the one added for release. Hans is living in a mansion from his inheritance, still ashamed, when Phroso, Venus and Frieda come to see him. Frieda tells him not to blame himself, and that she still loves him. They embrace.
There are quieter stories running alongside the main one, and they matter. The Bearded Lady, in love with the Human Skeleton, gives birth to their daughter, and the news travels through the troupe. Violet, one of the conjoined twins, becomes engaged to the circus owner. These are ordinary lives — weddings, births, proposals, arguments — and Browning films them as ordinary lives. That is the point the film keeps making, and the point its first audiences could not bear: these people are not a spectacle. They are a community. The monsters in the film are the two beautiful, able-bodied people who walk into it.
The cast
The billing leads with Wallace Ford as Phroso, the clown; Leila Hyams as Venus, the sea-lion trainer; Olga Baclanova as Cleopatra; and Roscoe Ates as Roscoe, the stuttering clown. Henry Victor plays Hercules, the strongman. Harry Earles plays Hans, and Daisy Earles plays Frieda.
Harry and Daisy Earles were real-life brother and sister, two of four siblings with dwarfism who performed together as the Doll Family. Harry had worked with Browning before, in The Unholy Three (1925), and it was Harry who first brought Browning the short story the film is based on.
The rest of the troupe were working sideshow and circus performers, cast as themselves in the only sense that matters: they were doing, on screen, the work they did for a living. Daisy and Violet Hilton were real-life conjoined twins. Johnny Eck, billed as the Half-Boy, was a legless performer. Josephine Joseph was billed as Half Woman-Half Man. Frances O’Connor was the armless girl. Peter Robinson was the Human Skeleton. Olga Roderick was the Bearded Lady. Koo Koo was the Bird Girl. Prince Randian, billed as the Living Torso, was a performer without arms or legs, remembered in the film for rolling and lighting a cigarette using only his mouth. Angelo Rossitto played Angeleno, who leads the wedding chant. Schlitzie played himself.
A word of care here, because the film’s history demands it. The title and the 1932 billing use a word for these performers that we would not use now, and that the film itself turns back on the people who use it. The performers in Freaks are not curiosities in the story. They are the people with a code, a community, and a claim on the audience’s sympathy. Cleopatra and Hercules, the beautiful ones, are the ones who lie, steal, and poison. Browning’s sympathies are not in doubt, even when the film’s last minutes are at their cruellest.
Two things about the cast are not settled, and should not be stated as settled. Schlitzie’s real name is sometimes given as Simon Metz, but the sources themselves say nobody is certain, and the claim is disputed. And the film is sometimes described as having been intended as a vehicle for Lon Chaney — that rests on a single source and has not been verified.
How it was made
Freaks is based on elements from “Spurs”, a short story by Tod Robbins first published in Munsey’s Magazine in February 1923. MGM bought the rights in the mid-1920s at Browning’s urging, for a reported $8,000. Cedric Gibbons, MGM’s art department chief and a childhood friend of Robbins, was responsible for the purchase.
The screenplay was written by Willis Goldbeck and Leon Gordon, with additional dialogue by Edgar Allan Woolf and Al Boasberg. The working title was Spurs. Tod Browning produced as well as directed, with Harry Rapf and Irving Thalberg as uncredited co-producers. Merritt B. Gerstad was the cinematographer, and Basil Wrangell edited.
Browning had worked with a travelling carnival before he became a filmmaker, and he had directed Dracula for Universal the year before. That success is what got Freaks made. Thalberg wanted another horror film to compete with Universal’s Dracula and Frankenstein, and Browning wanted to make this one.
Principal photography began in November 1931, on a 24-day schedule, on the MGM lot in Culver City, California. The exact start day is not settled — two historians give different days in November — so this page gives November 1931 only. Filming was completed on 16 December 1931, and Browning began retakes on 23 December.
The starting budget was about $209,000. It eventually grew to more than $300,000. The final budget is usually given as about $310,000, with one scholar giving the figure to the cent as $310,607.37 — but other published figures differ, so that exact number should not be treated as settled.
Casting the leads took some doing. Myrna Loy was first set for Cleopatra and Jean Harlow for Venus, and Victor McLaglen was considered for Hercules. Thalberg decided against major stars, and the Russian actress Olga Baclanova was cast as Cleopatra instead.
During the shoot, most of the sideshow performers were kept off the main studio lot in a specially built tent, and sent to a separate cafeteria. Only the Hilton sisters and the Earles were allowed on the main lot. It is an ugly detail, and it belongs in the record, because it is the same contempt the film itself is about — the studio treating its own cast the way Cleopatra treats the troupe.
The cut, and what was lost
The test screenings in January 1932 were disastrous. Audience members ran out halfway through — they did not walk out, they ran. Some became ill or fainted. One woman threatened to sue MGM, claiming the film had caused her to suffer a miscarriage.
In response, Irving Thalberg, without Browning’s consent, cut the original film — about 90 minutes long — down to just over an hour. About 26 minutes were cut. What went included most of the attack on Cleopatra under a lightning-struck tree, the sequence in which Hercules is castrated and made into a castrato, several comedy scenes of the performers’ daily lives, and most of the original epilogue, in which Hercules sang in a falsetto voice while Cleopatra quacked alongside him.
That footage is lost. It was never archived, and it is considered lost. To pad the running time back out, a new prologue featuring a carnival barker was added, and the alternate epilogue in which Hans and Frieda are reconciled.
The film that survives is 64 minutes long. Any listing that promises a longer cut is wrong.
The film had its world premiere at the Fox Theatre in San Diego on 28 January 1932, shown in full, before the cuts. Its Los Angeles premiere was at the Fox Criterion on 12 February 1932, according to Wikipedia; the AFI Catalog lists the release date as 20 February 1932, and notes that the exact date of the Los Angeles opening has not been determined. This page gives both dates rather than settling the question. The New York opening came later, on 8 July 1932 at the Rialto.
It was not banned by the Hays Office — the film was made before the Production Code was enforced, in 1934. The censorship came from everywhere else. MGM censored it first. Atlanta pulled it from screenings. Canada’s censors called it “brutal and grotesque”. After the New York run ended in the summer of 1932, MGM withdrew the film entirely. It is the only MGM film ever pulled from release before completing its domestic engagements.
In Britain, the censors refused it a certificate outright in 1932, and refused it again in 1952. It was finally passed with an X certificate in August 1963 — 31 years after it was made.
What it earned, and what it cost
Freaks was a box-office failure on its first release. It grossed $289,000 in the United States and $52,000 internationally, for a total of $341,000, and MGM recorded a total loss of $164,000. It earned more in smaller cities — Cincinnati, Boston, Saint Paul — than in larger ones such as Los Angeles and Chicago.
MGM sold the distribution rights to Dwain Esper for $50,000 for 25 years. Esper toured it through carnivals and grindhouses under new titles: The Monster Story, Forbidden Love, and Nature’s Mistakes. For three decades, that was the only way to see it.
Browning made four more films after Freaks and retired in 1939. The film is often said to have ended his career as a major director, and the record supports the shape of that claim, even if the exact wording is a matter of judgement: after Dracula, he never had another success on that scale.
The long way back
The turn came in Europe. Freaks was screened at the 1962 Venice Film Festival, and French critics, who had rediscovered Browning as a serious filmmaker, championed it. Through the 1970s it became a midnight movie in the United States. In 1994 — 62 years after its release — the Library of Congress selected it for preservation in the United States National Film Registry.
The reappraisal has held. The film is now widely considered among Browning’s best, and it is listed in the reference book 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die. Its most quoted scene, the wedding banquet chant — “We accept her, we accept her, one of us, one of us. Gooble gobble, gooble gobble” — has travelled far beyond the film: the Ramones built their 1977 song “Pinhead” on it, turning “Gooble gobble” into “Gabba Gabba Hey”.
There is a reason the film lasted when so many of its contemporaries did not. It is not the shock of the ending, though the ending is shocking. It is the hour before it: people eating dinner, arguing about a baby, proposing marriage, lighting a cigarette with no hands. Browning shows a community that looks after its own, and two beautiful outsiders who do not. The horror is not in the bodies on screen. It is in the discovery that the monsters were the normal-looking people all along — and that the people the audience came to stare at were the ones worth standing with.











